[Alpha_522]

Winner of the contest:

DarkShadowLurker

  Spoiler: sig 

Please congrats him

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
VOTING IS CLOSED.

Anyone is able to vote

You may only vote once and not yourself. Just reply to this topic to vote, state why you vote for that sig.

EDIT: Why no poll?
http://www.tailedfox.com/forums/cont...html#post83945

Vote will end on September 2nd, 2008

BlizzarD:

  Spoiler: sig 

Haruno Sakura:

  Spoiler: sig 

Kakashi

  Spoiler: sig 

Darkkyuubi

  Spoiler: sig 

DarkShadowLurker

  Spoiler: sig 

Alpha_522

  Spoiler: sig 

SilentNovA

  Spoiler: sig 

[Varemia]

I'm not sure whether this is exclusive for TS members, but the rules don't say that so I'll cast my vote.

Man this is a hard one. I'm split between kakashi gaiden and haruno sakura. Um, um, Kakashi! I like that one the best.

My vote is Kakashi, the reason I didn't like others was for colorfulness, errors, and the element of coolness. kakashi's employs it all, rock solid and very cool.

[SilentNovA]

It was a tough choice

KG's and BlizzarD's were good, Sakura's was awesome

but in the end, I voted for DarkShadow, good job dude.

[ichijin]

Critique-
BlizzarD: I commend the appropriate colors, but that wavy pattern on the left seems a little out of place... The Naruto's elbow is cut off slightly, yet the render itself is a good quality. The close up fades in pretty well. The text is nice and clear.

Haruno Sakura: Looks great apparently, good render, good effects, but the text was a little eye watering to read... A little small, but still readable. The icy effects match fairly well too.

Kakashi: First thing I notice is the text, pretty nice text, and nice use of coloring. For a moment there I thought the text was going to be hard, since it was all orange, the whole thing, first thing I thought was orange. Same render as BlizzarD, and of course, good quality, I do quite like the autumn leaves effects too. And having the wavyness in the background rather than being easily noticed works well too.

DarkKyuubi: Three pictures... This layout is, as I stress, cliche. Central picture, one on the right, and another on the left. Thunder effects aren't bad, but when I get to the parts where they swirl rounded curves, it doesn't look like thunder, but more like traveling neon lights. The renders didn't quite match... The middle had the best quality, the right had the worst, and the left was simply average... I never noticed the text first either, it's nice, but doesn't quite match the effects being used.

DarkShadowLurker: To begin with, the render's great, the effects work well, and the words are as clear as day, the only thing is that it seems a little dull... Depressing in some cases if you may, due to the use of darker, duller colors. If it's meant to give that effect, then consider that a compliment.

Alpha_522: The most unique of them all, while the words may be eye watering to read, it's also quite plain, color wise. The pictures of Akatsuki's three, most important members were used appropriately, I guess the back of the foot panel was for dramatic purposes, and I'm not sure how to put it, but the middle panel works quite well, delivering a dramatic, "going into the sunset" effect. Though, it already got brownie points for being the most unique.

SilentNovA: The cutest of them all I guess, the pink, circle arrow thing works quite well in giving it the cuteness effect, and the background makes them look like, they're dashing through a forest. Though, the background doesn't quite match the picture... it blends, but it just... Doesn't quite fit, but it's a good background nonetheless.

I'm placing my vote on Alpha... for Uniqueness

This thread lacks Poll D:<

[ayane]

Hm.
I vote for Alpha_522. It's just...so simple but so beautiful . Even though Sakura made great job, too.

[Yagami]

so did they like make these by themselves?anyway i vote alpha.its colorful in its own way.

[BlizzarD]

yeh as you see all the sigs are hand made and they are not ripped... we made them by our selves(thats why my sig is so crappy )
iam voting for the kakashi not becous the render is the same as mine... lol its just good efects and really good made background

[KigaOmoi]

I vote for Alpha .... cuz I like the style....

[BlizzarD]

also this thread need poll alpha plx put it in

[Alpha_522]

Originally Posted by BlizzarD

also this thread need poll alpha plx put it in

poll isn't an effective way to vote when it comes to signature or any gfx. People will just vote without giving a reason thus that is not useful. Its like saying they don't care when they should. People put effort in their work, they should at least give a comment why they chose that one. Anyone is able to vote